Bayesian model averaging to explore the worth of data for soil-plant model selection and prediction
A Bayesian model averaging (BMA) framework is presented to evaluate the worth of different observation types and experimental design options for (1) more confidence in model selection and (2) for increased predictive reliability. These two modeling tasks are handled separately because model selection aims at identifying the most appropriate model with respect to a given calibration data set, while predictive reliability aims at reducing uncertainty in model predictions through constraining the plausible range of both models and model parameters. For that purpose, we pursue an optimal design of measurement framework that is based on BMA and that considers uncertainty in parameters, measurements, and model structures. We apply this framework to select between four crop models (the vegetation components of CERES, SUCROS, GECROS, and SPASS), which are coupled to identical routines for simulating soil carbon and nitrogen turnover, soil heat and nitrogen transport, and soil water movement. An ensemble of parameter realizations was generated for each model using Monte-Carlo simulation. We assess each model's plausibility by determining its posterior weight, which signifies the probability to have generated a given experimental data set. Several BMA analyses were conducted for different data packages with measurements of soil moisture, evapotranspiration (ETₐ), and leaf area index (LAI). The posterior weights resulting from the different BMA runs were compared to the weight distribution of a reference run with all data types to investigate the utility of different data packages and monitoring design options in identifying the most appropriate model in the ensemble. We found that different (combinations of) data types support different models an d none of the four crop models outperforms all others under all data scenarios. The best model discrimination was observed for those data where the competing models disagree the most. The data worth for reducing prediction uncertainty depends on the prediction to be made. LAI data have the highest utility for predicting ETₐ, while soil moisture data are better for predicting soil water drainage. Our study illustrates, that BMA provides an objective framework for data worth analysis with respect to both model discrimination and model calibration for a wide range of applications. Key Points: BMA provides a data worth analysis framework for model selection and calibration BMA does not converge to the "true" model Different data types support different models and none outperforms all others... [Show full abstract]
KeywordsBayesian model averaging; crop models; soil characteristics; leaf area index; evapotranspiration; soil moisture; data worth; model selection; soil-plant modeling; Environmental Engineering
Fields of Research0406 Physical Geography and Environmental Geoscience; 0905 Civil Engineering; 0907 Environmental Engineering
© 2015. American Geophysical Union. All Rights Reserved.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Narouei-Khandan, Hossein Ali (Lincoln University, 2014)In recent decades, species distribution models (SDMs) have been widely used in many ecological, environmental and climate-change research studies to model invasive species establishment. These models associate recorded ...
An empirical investigation of the effectiveness and robustness of asset pricing models in Australia : A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy at Lincoln University Malik, Saba (Lincoln University, 2020)With a plethora of asset pricing models, it is hard to determine: Which model is relatively better than other models in successfully explaining the returns of the capital assets in an equity market? and if any of the ...
Agricultural Economics Research Unit (Lincoln College. Agricultural Economics Research Unit, 1970-08)This paper represents a further stage in the programme of work initiated at Lincoln some years ago under the general heading of Studies in the Structure of the New Zealand Economy, This has involved the compilation of data ...