User knowledge and audit expectations gap in Sri Lanka
The widespread criticism and litigation against auditors has frequently been attributed to the existence of an expectations gap between the auditing profession and the public. An audit expectations gap is said to exist when there are differences in the beliefs of auditors and the public about the duties and responsibilities of auditors, and the meaning of messages conveyed by the audit report (Monroe & Woodliff, 1994). Researchers suggest that the gap is attributable to both unreasonable public expectations (the reasonableness gap) and inadequate auditor performance (the performance gap), whether due to deficient auditing standards (deficient standards gap) or substandard auditor performance (deficient performance gap) (Porter, 1993). Most prior studies have investigated the expectations gap phenomenon in a developed country context. This study extends the generalisability of prior studies by investigating whether a reasonableness expectations gap is evident in Sri Lanka -a developing country. In particular, the study determines whether significant differences can be observed between auditors and the other groups, with regards to the role, objectives, and limitations of an external audit, and the message(s) conveyed in the audit report. The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Sri Lanka has asserted that an expectations gap does exist in Sri Lanka, and that unreasonable user expectations are primarily to blame. This study aims to provide evidence useful in assessing the validity of the claims of the Sri Lankan accounting profession. Further, the study investigates whether the extent of the reasonableness gap is influenced by level of audit sophistication (knowledge) amongst non-auditor subjects. A smaller reasonableness gap is expected to be associated with sophisticated groups (e.g., managers, accountants, bankers, lawyers) relative to less sophisticated groups (e.g., private shareholders and students). This study is not concerned with issues relating to the setting of audit regulations, adequacy of the standards or the performance of the audit profession, but with the communication and understanding of current regulations and the intended meaning of unqualified audit report. The data for the study are collected by means of a self-administered questionnaire, which comprised of semantic differential belief statements. The survey included auditors, students, bankers, lawyers and preparers of financial statements. The results confirmed the existence of an audit expectations gap in Sri Lanka and suggest that the degree of audit sophistication amongst non-auditors is associated with the degree of unreasonable audit expectations. The study found that differences in the perceptions of non auditors and auditors concerning the auditor's responsibilities for fraud detection and reporting; and the meaning of the unqualified audit report, were important determinants of the extent of the unreasonableness gap. Contributing somewhat less to the unreasonableness gap were differences in perceptions concerning the auditor's responsibility for maintaining accounting records and the view that an unqualified audit report assures that entity is being run efficiently.... [Show full abstract]
KeywordsSri Lanka; auditing; financial reporting; fiscal balance; audit expectations gap; auditing standards; audit procedures; accounting; fraud detection; audit report; surveys
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
An empirical study of the changes in the level of audit fees in New Zealand over a period of 11 years Lee Andy, C. H. (Lincoln University, 1999)Previous studies on this topic have found that audit fees decreased after professional accounting bodies made changes in Codes of Ethics. These changes allowed audit firms to advertise their services, tender for audit ...
Premchun Penpilai (Lincoln University, 1998)Previous research has suggested that audit firm structure can explain a number of variations in audit fee profile. This thesis focuses on the efficiency effects of audit firm structure by examining the external audit fee ...
The effect of control risk, audit firm size and auditor change on audit fees : an empirical study in New Zealand Yeung, Mo L. (Lincoln University, 1999)Concerns about the rising costs of external audit services in the 1970's prompted a series of research studies in an attempt to provide more understanding of the fee setting process and of the behaviour of the audit market. ...