Research@Lincoln
    • Login
     
    View Item 
    •   Research@Lincoln Home
    • Theses and Dissertations
    • Doctoral (PhD) Theses
    • View Item
    •   Research@Lincoln Home
    • Theses and Dissertations
    • Doctoral (PhD) Theses
    • View Item
    JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

    Cutting up the high country: the social construction of tenure review and ecological sustainability

    McFarlane, Jean
    Abstract
    Tenure review is the name given to the process of dividing New Zealand's South Island high country Crown pastoral leases between primary production and biodiversity conservation held as freehold tenure or full Crown ownership and control respectively. The process, started without a clear statutory mandate in 1991, was subsequently legitimated by enacting the Crown Pastoral Land Act 1998. In addition to providing for the division already mentioned, the new legislation included the object s24(a)(i) that required tenure review 'promotes ecologically sustainable management' of the lands in question. The tenure review process has been accompanied by an intense contest between some stakeholders that has created polarised support for either production or conservation and their corresponding ownership form. However s24(a)(i) is relatively absent in the discourse surrounding tenure review. This research aims to investigate this absence and identify the consequences. A qualitative epistemology was adopted based on a grounded social constructionist approach. The discourse (including interviews) relating to history, legislation, government policy and reports, ecology and ecosystem management, high country science, and the current stakeholders (the scientists, the runholders, the ENGOs, Fish and Game, Ngai Tahu, the Department of Conservation and Land Information New Zealand) was analysed and interpreted from a social constructionist perspective. The emergent social constructions revealed that the sidelining of s24(a)(i) met the needs of each of the three 'official' parties to tenure review, albeit in different ways. This sidelining also had the effect of silencing those not designated as 'official' where their advocacy was based on the concepts of ecological sustainability and ecosystem management. Recommendations are made for institutional reform necessary to successfully implement what is interpreted as a particularly appropriate conceptual basis for the environmental protection of the degradation prone and productively marginal high country tussock grasslands.... [Show full abstract]
    Keywords
    tenure review; tussock grasslands; South Island; New Zealand; high country; ecological sustainability; social construction of nature; ecosystem management; Crown Pastoral Land Act 1998
    Date
    2011
    Type
    Thesis
    Collections
    • Doctoral (PhD) Theses [753]
    • Department of Environmental Management [961]
    Thumbnail
    View/Open
    McFarlane_PhD.pdf (11.13Mb)
    Permalink
    https://hdl.handle.net/10182/4134
    Metadata
     Expand record
    This service is managed by Library, Teaching and Learning
    • Archive Policy
    • Copyright and Reuse
    • Deposit Guidelines and FAQ
    • Contact Us
     

     

    Browse

    All of Research@LincolnCommunities & CollectionsTitlesAuthorsKeywordsBy Issue DateThis CollectionTitlesAuthorsKeywordsBy Issue Date

    My Account

    LoginRegister

    Statistics

    View Usage Statistics
    This service is managed by Library, Teaching and Learning
    • Archive Policy
    • Copyright and Reuse
    • Deposit Guidelines and FAQ
    • Contact Us