Ensemble models to assess the risk of exotic plant pathogens in a changing climate
In recent decades, species distribution models (SDMs) have been widely used in many ecological, environmental and climate-change research studies to model invasive species establishment. These models associate recorded locations of species with environmental variables. Nevertheless, the few studies that attempt to model the climate suitability of plant pathogens before their arrival into a new area mainly rely on a single model projection. In this research, eleven species distribution models (in the form of three modelling approaches which include correlative and mechanistic models) were used to project the climate suitability of three target species; kiwifruit bacterial canker (Pseudomonas syringae pv. actinidia) (Psa), dwarf bunt of wheat (Tellitia controversa) and guava rust (Puccinia psidii) for New Zealand and over a global scale. The climate suitability of target species was modelled using CLIMEX as a semi-mechanistic model, MaxEnt as a presence-only correlative model and Multi-Model Framework (which includes nine correlative models). While there were similarities with regard to climate suitability for target species projected by the models over both local and global scales, there were differences in their projection with respect to the degree and extent of suitability, making it hard to select one “best” model. All models were found to have their differences and weaknesses that are largely the result of difference in the theoretical basis and structure of each model. For example, compared with CLIMEX and the Multi-Model Framework, MaxEnt showed lower transferability of projection into new areas. Additionally, as a semi -mechanistic model, the uncertainty of CLIMEX projections was found to be increased by subjectivity in the parameter setting process. To illustrate the impact of parameter variability on the uncertainty of CLIMEX projections, a sensitivity analysis was performed on one of the target species (dwarf bunt) to measure the effect of error in important parameters on model output. The sensitivity analysis showed that for dwarf bunt, CLIMEX outputs were very sensitive to upper temperature threshold and soil moisture parameters, which highlight that sensitivity analysis, should be an integral part of any CLIMEX modelling. For Multi-Model, despite the advantages such as calculating different performance criteria, the importance and contribution of selected variables and their influence on model output is not given. Because of differences in model projection, a method was developed to benefit from the information provided by all the types of models, by combining the results of different model output into an ensemble, or more specifically, a consensus model. A variant of committee averaging was used where model outputs are converted to binary maps (presence- absence) which allow any kind of algorithm and output to be included. The resulting consensus model highlighted the areas where more than half of the models agreed on the climate suitability for target species establishment. Such a model that relies on agreement of model projections indicates with a level of certainty or uncertainty what is likely to happen and consequently can highlight areas, both locally and globally, that have a higher risk of target species establishment. Finally, the effect of climate change on climate suitability of target species was investigated using two scenarios (A1B and A2) for 2030 and 2090. The results showed that, the suitable areas decreased for Psa and dwarf bunt at different levels while guava rust suitability increased. The results of this thesis confirm that models with different theoretical foundation will give dissimilar predictions, and it is difficult to determine conclusively whether one model is superior to others. Among other recommendations, I strongly advise that researchers and risk assessors should not rely on a single-model projection. If time and resources are available, an appropriate ensemble of models should be used to investigate the climate suitability of plant pathogens. Keywords: Plant pathogens, kiwifruit bacterial canker (Psa), dwarf bunt, guava rust, climate suitability, Species distribution models (SDMs), CLIMEX, MaxEnt, Multi-Model Framework, correlative models, semi-mechanistic models, sensitivity analysis, consensus model, ensemble models, climate change, range expansion.... [Show full abstract]
KeywordsPlant pathogens; kiwifruit bacterial canker (Psa); dwarf bunt; guava rust; climate suitability; Species distribution models (SDMs); CLIMEX; MaxEnt; Multi-Model Framework; correlative models; semi-mechanistic models; sensitivity analysis; consensus model; ensemble models; climate change; range expansion
Fields of Research050103 Invasive Species Ecology; 050206 Environmental Monitoring; 070104 Agricultural Spatial Analysis and Modelling; 060704 Plant Pathology
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Agricultural Economics Research Unit (Lincoln College. Agricultural Economics Research Unit, 1970-08)This paper represents a further stage in the programme of work initiated at Lincoln some years ago under the general heading of Studies in the Structure of the New Zealand Economy, This has involved the compilation of data ...
Wong Janet (Lincoln University, 1995)The high rate of new product failure is decreased through the use of new product forecasting models (NPFMs). There is a particular lack of studies and applications of NPFMs in the NZ (New Zealand) context. The purpose of ...
An evaluation of irrigation-yield repsonse models for use with wheat & barley in Canterbury, New Zealand Baird, John R. (Lincoln College, University of Canterbury, 1986)This study evaluated the ability of nine models to describe and predict the response of grain yield to flood irrigation of wheat and barley crops. The models may be divided into four groups: 1). Input-Output models 2). ...